Automatic vs Manual: How to Choose the Right Rental Car for Your Costa del Sol Trip
Why the choice of transmission matters
When you plan to rent a car for your Costa del Sol adventure, one of the early decisions is whether to pick an automatic or a manual transmission vehicle. Each option brings benefits and trade-offs. At Fetajo Rent a Car we offer both types across our fleet—from compact city models to family SUVs and premium cars—so you can tailor the vehicle to your itinerary, driving experience and comfort preferences.
Understanding the difference between manual and automatic
What distinguishes the two
A manual transmission requires the driver to engage the clutch pedal and shift gears manually. An automatic transmission manages gear changes for you, without clutch pedal operation. While manual cars have been the norm in Spain and much of Europe, automatics are increasingly popular—particularly among international visitors.
Why manual is still widespread
Manual cars still dominate Spanish roads. They are generally more available in rental fleets and often come at lower rental rates because the supply is higher. If budget is a major factor, manual could make sense. For drivers accustomed to stick-shifts—especially European drivers—manual offers a familiar dynamic.
Pros of renting a manual car
Greater control and driving engagement
For people comfortable with manual shifting, driving a manual car can feel more engaging—especially on scenic routes, mountain roads or when you want to manage engine braking and gear changes yourself. In the Costa del Sol region, with its varied terrain, that direct control can be a plus.
Better value and availability
Since manual cars are far more common in Spain, rental companies often charge less for them compared to automatics. If your driving style and traffic conditions allow it, you may achieve more value.
Ideal for experienced stick-shift drivers
If you routinely drive a manual vehicle at home, choosing a manual rental will feel natural. You’ll likely make the most of the many winding roads, countryside drives and coastal scenic routes found along Andalusia.
Pros of renting an automatic car
Easier driving and less fatigue
An automatic transmission simplifies the driving task: no clutch, no gear stick changes to worry about. For many international visitors—especially from countries where automatics are the standard—this offers peace of mind. Particularly in traffic-heavy areas like Málaga, Marbella or Fuengirola, an automatic can make the experience much smoother.
Better for urban or mixed routes
If your itinerary includes city driving, frequent stops or narrow streets, an automatic car spares you the extra effort of constant gear changes. Also beneficial for longer stays or if you’ll be doing a lot of driving per day.
Suitable for newer or occasional drivers
If you’re less confident with manual gearboxes, renting automatic can reduce stress and allow you focus on navigation, scenery and enjoying your trip rather than on mastering the clutch.
Which one should you pick for your Costa del Sol stay?
Select manual if…
- You are experienced with manual shifting and comfortable with it.
- Your budget is tight and you want the lowest rental rate possible.
- You plan to drive rural roads, mountain passes or less congested areas where manual control may be an advantage.
Select automatic if…
- You prefer a smooth, relaxed drive without the extra effort of gear changes.
- You will spend much time in urban areas, coastal towns, or routes with frequent stops.
- You come from a country where automatics are the norm and feel more at ease with them.
At Fetajo Rent a Car, all our vehicles—manual or automatic—are routinely maintained, thoroughly cleaned and come with full insurance. Whichever you choose, you’re covered.
Practical considerations: fuel, performance and booking
Fuel efficiency and engine performance
Traditionally, manual vehicles offered better fuel economy. But modern automatics—including dual-clutch and CVT systems—have narrowed that gap significantly. If fuel consumption is a priority, note that Fetajo lists engine type, fuel usage and emissions for each model so you can compare and decide.
Availability & booking lead time
Since manual cars dominate the local fleet, they are generally easier to book. Automatic cars—due to higher demand by foreign renters—may be less available, especially during the high season. Reserve early if you want automatic.
Comfort for families or longer drives
For families, seniors or drivers planning long distances, automatic cars often provide extra comfort: smoother gear transitions, less leg fatigue, easier hill starts. Manuals may be more fun for drivers who relish control.
The important choice, manual rental car or Automatic rental car
Choosing between an automatic or manual rental car on the Costa del Sol ultimately depends on your driving experience, route plan and preferred comfort level. Manual cars offer value, control and are plentiful. Automatics offer convenience, ease and often more comfort for urban or unfamiliar roads. With Fetajo Rent a Car you can choose the transmission type that fits you best—and rest assured knowing you’ll have a well-maintained vehicle and support service backing your journey.
Whether you want the hands-on feel of a manual on scenic seals or the effortless ease of an automatic through city stops and beach drives—your Andalusian road adventure begins when you turn the key. And with Fetajo, you’re in good hands.